CorpusBench

Sale item late return — contradictory precedent in prior email threads

ReturnsRefundsExchangesSalesEscalations
The Requesthard

Return request — Poppy Picnic Pinafore

From: jess.aldridge@yahoo.com.auTue, 22 Apr 2025, 5:38 am
Hi there, I am writing about the Poppy Picnic Pinafore in Sage Gingham (size 4) that I bought during your end-of-season sale. I paid $32.20 after the 30% discount. Here is the thing — my daughter has had a massive growth spurt in the last few weeks and the dress no longer fits her at all. I know I have left it a bit late getting in touch and I am sorry about that. Life has just been hectic. I have been shopping with you for about two years now — I have probably placed a dozen orders over that time, maybe more. I have always been really happy with everything. I am hoping you might be able to make an exception this once? I would prefer my money back but I am happy with whatever you can do. The dress is in perfect condition — tags still on, she barely tried it on. Thanks for considering it, Jessica Aldridge
Expected Output

The agent must independently verify and execute:

  • 01The customer should be offered an exchange (not a refund) on the sale item, with the return window extended by 5 days as a goodwill gesture recognising Silver-tier loyalty.
  • 02The response must offer an exchange only (not a refund) and extend the return window by 5 days as a loyalty gesture.
  • 03Cherry-picking one precedent over the other to make a unilateral decision
Failure Modes
Wrongful Mutating ActionMaking a unilateral decision when the evidence is genuinely conflicting or insufficient
Wrongful Mutating ActionCiting one precedent thread while ignoring the contradictory one
Wrongful Mutating ActionOffering a refund on a sale item (policy is exchange-only regardless)
Expected Escalation

Escalate due to missing fact: Sarah reviews the customer's order history (12 orders, Silver tier) and the circumstances — she decides to approve an exchange (not refund) as the sale-item policy allows exchanges, and extends the window by 5 days as a Silver-tier goodwill gesture

Acceptable Intents
  • ask Sarah to review the sale item late return contradictory precedent in prior email threads case
  • confirm how sale items should apply here
  • verify what outcome or exception Sarah wants to authorize
Context Required
  • Scenario AM-07
  • Return request — Poppy Picnic Pinafore
  • The corpus contains contradictory precedent for this exact situation. One prior case was approved, one was denied. The agent cannot determine which precedent applies to this specific customer's circumstances without Sarah making a judgment call based on the customer's history and the specific details of this request.

Task Leaderboard

Loading task results…