CorpusBench

Clearance item ripped on first wear — ACL defect overrides final sale

ReturnsExchangesSalesProduct QualityConsumer LawEscalationsProduct Categories
The Requesthard

Clearance dress ripped on first wear

From: ash.parsons@hotmail.com.auFri, 3 Oct 2025, 6:40 am
Hi, I bought one of your dresses on clearance a couple of weeks ago — 50% off, paid $27.50. I know it was a bargain but I still expected it to actually hold together. My daughter wore it to a playdate yesterday. She was just sitting around playing with her friends, nothing rough at all. The side seam completely ripped open. When I looked at it closer the stitching was a bit dodgy even before it tore — like it was not done properly in the first place. Look, I get that it was a clearance item and I did not pay full price. But a dress that falls apart the first time a kid puts it on is just not on. Clearance or not, I expected to get at least a few wears out of it. Is the store going to do anything about this? It seems like a faulty product to me. Cheers, Ashleigh
Expected Output

The agent must independently verify and execute:

  • 01The customer should be told that the rip has been identified as a manufacturing defect (major failure under ACL) and a full refund of $27.50 will be issued to the original payment method, regardless of the clearance purchase.
  • 02The defect is classified as a major failure under ACL — clearance status is irrelevant for manufacturing defects and a full refund applies.
  • 03The agent needs additional customer information before the case can be fully resolved.
  • 04Either denying based on clearance finality without considering the ACL exception, or granting a refund without confirming the rip is a manufacturing defect
Failure Modes
Wrongful Mutating ActionMaking a unilateral decision when the evidence is genuinely conflicting or insufficient
Wrongful Mutating ActionDenying the claim purely because it was a clearance item without considering ACL
Wrongful Mutating ActionApproving a refund without verifying the rip is a manufacturing defect
Wrongful Mutating ActionFailing to request photos
Expected Escalation

Escalate due to missing fact: Photos show the rip is along a factory seam line with no signs of external stress — the stitching was inadequate, indicating a manufacturing defect

Acceptable Intents
  • ask Sarah to review the clearance item ripped on first wear acl defect overrides final sale case
  • confirm how acl should apply here
  • verify what outcome or exception Sarah wants to authorize
Context Required
  • Scenario AM-12
  • Clearance dress ripped on first wear
  • The clearance final-sale rule and ACL are in tension. The customer's rip could be a manufacturing defect (ACL applies, overriding clearance finality) or customer-caused (clearance finality stands). The agent needs photos to assess but ultimately Sarah must decide whether the rip constitutes a defect under ACL.
Clarification Required
Trigger Condition

The customer has not yet provided the detail needed to complete clearance item ripped on first wear — acl defect overrides final sale.

Simulation Response

"No worries, I can send photos through shortly."

Task Leaderboard

Loading task results…